British Military Administration: multiplicity and eccentricity - Lin Yangchen
©Lin Yangchen


previous section | next section | back to table of contents


The MV Phrontis (built 1926, displacement 6635 tons), seen here in Brisbane, was one of the ships that had evacuated coconut definitives to Melbourne at the outbreak of war in 1941/1942 (Peter Cockburn comm. 2017). The ship was sold to Saudi Arabia in 1958 and renamed the Ryad.

By the end of the war, more than 56 million coconut definitives remained in mint condition in London, Kuala Lumpur, and Melbourne. Several months before the Japanese surrender, the Crown Agents engaged De La Rue to secretly overprint the stamps with bma malaya, and repack them in the original cases if these were sturdy enough to withstand rough handling and beach landings (Cockburn 1998). De La Rue manufactured three plates of which two were sent to Kuala Lumpur and Melbourne (Walton 1972, Morris 2017). The coconut definitive was perfect for pan-Malaya use, since it carried the king's portrait instead of a specific state sultan.


The typesetter has apparently taken care to both kern and letterspace the glyphs appropriately with respect to one another and to their surroundings, placing the pairs la, ay and ya closer together and spacing out bma. The overprint holds yet another typographic surprise: its two lines are in slightly different typefaces. The malaya has narrower letters for economy of space; more unexpectedly, stroke width is constant in bma but variable in malaya. The author suspects that this latter difference, obviously not meant to be perceived by the normal user, may have been an aid for weeding out less meticulous forgeries. Notwithstanding, the author wonders if the overprint could not have been more succinct in the form of a simple bma in larger and heavier lettering, avoiding the repetition of malaya on the stamp.

Only 100 to 200 copies of the overprint essay on the grey 8 cents are known to have escaped destruction by the postal authorities, a few of the stamps making it onto philatelic covers (Cockburn 1998).

The Japanese surrender on 12 September 1945 at the Municipal Building, Singapore. Signing the document is the Supreme Allied Commander, South East Asia Command, Admiral of the Fleet Lord Louis Mountbatten, who subsequently assumed direct command of the British Military Administration. Source: Imperial War Museum.

The British were late, arriving in Malaya almost three weeks after the Japanese surrender. It was only because of false rumours of immediate British return that the nationalistic Kesatuan Rakyat Indonesia Semenanjung in Kuala Lumpur did not declare independence (Cheah 2003), an act that would probably have killed the coconut definitive.

Postmarked in Kota Bahru, Kelantan, the start point of the Japanese invasion of Malaya that ultimately led to the British Military Administration.

Malaya was a mess (Donnison 1956). Murder was “extremely common”, far more than the hundreds of reported cases. So dire was the state of affairs that police barricaded themselves in their stations for safety. Piracy was so rampant along the west coast of the peninsula that even ships in harbour were not safe. Public infrastructure was dilapidated, and malnutrition and malaria had spread.

The stamp situation was no less chaotic. To begin with, the stamps that had been overprinted in London before the surrender were misplaced in transit from Ceylon, forcing Malaya's Chief Civil Affairs Officer Major-General Sir Ralph Hone to order post offices to reopen anyway and accept unstamped mail (letter forwarded to Gibbons Stamp Monthly in January 1967). He said it helped locals keep in touch with their loved ones in difficult times.

Later, the Crown Agents ordered De La Rue to print more stamps of various denominations as pre-war stocks turned out to be insufficient (Proud 2000); see Vousden (1996b) for printing and overprinting locations by denomination. Due to post-war disorganization and constant changes of policy, stamps were dispersed all over the shop and orders were unrealistically small (Cockburn 1998), creating a fertile breeding ground for variations, plate flaws and printing errors; see Cameron (1950), Wells (1963, 1968), Pratt (1968), Ruffle (1964), Stanway (1991, 1992), Tyre (1991), Barker (1993), Peters (1994), Robinson (1994), Hale (2002), Crabtree (2012), Pollard (2000a, 2012), Brown (2015, 2017a), Chum (2015), Cockburn (1998, 2015, 2016a), Murray Payne (2015a,b), Brown (2017c), Morris (2017) and Staffeldt (2017).

Poor Die I (left) and Die II prints suffering from plate wear and/or bad ink. The 10 cents has a shifted vignette causing a clash of background lines.

These stamps may be Kuala Lumpur or Melbourne overprintings that evaded London's quality control, exhibiting some of the largest shifts ever observed in BMA overprints, with both horizontal and vertical dislocation. Morris (2017) noted that the Commonwealth Bank of Australia, which overprinted stamps there, "prided themselves on not wasting a single stamp". Overprint creep has most notably been highlighted in the 5c (e.g. Chum 2015), but those are very minor fractional displacements compared to these.

There was even a "metallic" overprint reported on some examples of the 50 cents, which the author believes is an intense ink thinly printed. The ink's bright red colour, visually mixed with the underlying black ink showing through, gives the impression of shiny metal.

Coconut tree climbers ascend with the aid of a rope lashed between the feet to produce friction against the trunk. They sometimes train monkeys to do the harvest instead. The coconut's scientific name Cocos was itself derived from the Portuguese word for "monkey", on account of the three spots on the nut that make it look like a monkey's head (McCurrach 1960).

A coconut can fall and hit you on the head
And if it falls from high enough can kind of knock you dead

Frederick Seidel

The notorious 'falling coconut' plate flaw just below the lowest frond on the right-hand palm, from the London printing of Plate 1 (Hale 2002). Like shark attacks, falling coconuts hitting people are rare but dangerous enough to be documented as a categorical cause of death.

Close-up of the 'falling coconut'. The appearance of the flaw suggests that it was due to some kind of contamination or disturbance during the electroplating process rather than to an accidental knock on the finished plate.


High chance of falling coconuts: a multi-pronged coconut tree (Furtado 1924) in Malaya.

Parts of the plates of the Die II 2c orange and 6c grey seemed to have worn out faster than usual, producing progressive 'white forehead' varieties in which the frontal facial features of the king were increasingly devoid of lines (Cameron 1950, McClaren 2001, Pollard 2001, Toh 2001, Chang 2003). Such differential wear and tear may be a consequence of the plate having infinitesimal deviations from perfect flatness. Peter Cockburn (comm. 2017), however, attributed these varieties to variations in plate pressure.


Close-up of the 'white forehead'.

It is a mystery why the Die I print of the 2 cents exists at all and where it originated (Malaya Study Group 1993), since pre-war Die II plates were presumably available. Could logistical complications have somehow necessitated the manufacture of a separate 2c duty plate? Peter Cockburn (comm. 2017) speculates that the single working plate was damaged, necessitating the use of the pre-war 2-cent duty plate. The key plate of the stamp on the left is slightly lighter than its duty plate, while the converse is true for the stamp on the right. The medallion rims are darkened by overlapping lines, creating organic nuances of colour, like the skin and flesh of a juicy orange, that are only possible in a Die I print.


The 2 cents Die I in a jumble of Die II's.

Three two-tone varieties of the 10 cents on three different types of paper—substitute, chalky and striated. The composite image of each of the first two stamps shows the left half of the stamp under 365 nm longwave ultraviolet irradiation (methodology) and the right half in daylight. The presence of aniline inks is indicated by "volcanic lava" fluorescence. While only the key plate fluoresces in the first stamp, both key and duty plates fluoresce—to different degrees—in the second. The third stamp does not fluoresce appreciably; it is seen here in daylight.


Symmetry in a registered letter from Singapore to Scotland.

Even postmarks were sometimes messed up, with misspelt SNIGAPORE double-ring cancellations appearing from 14 March to 11 April 1947 (Chua 1987). Interestingly, the author occasionally makes the same error on the keyboard when he types too fast. But back then it was the necessity of focusing one's attention on the carving of individual glyphs that gave birth to this notorious typo.

It was perhaps because of wartime neglect and damage that this circular datestamp was missing its month slug, here filled in with pencil. I spotted this in a large old leatherbound accounts book that a retired collector had used as a stamp album. He peeled the stamp off by its hinge and let me have it for $2. Yet it wasn't about the financial transaction; it was the passing of stewardship of history from one generation to the next.

Postmarked on Christmas Island, which was administered from Singapore from 1946 to 1958. Christmas Island is the only location where the geographical range of the coconut definitive overlapped with that of the coconut crab Birgus latro Linnaeus 1767. The largest hermit crab in the world, its legs span more than a metre and its claws pinch with very nearly the force of a lion's jaws. Its flesh has a subtle coconut aroma, originating from one of its favourite foods. See The Straits Times for more on the species' natural history.

The military administration lasted less than a year. Even before the civilian government actually took over, philatelic dealers began panic buying over speculation that the stamps may be withdrawn from circulation (The Straits Times, 14 January 1946). As it turned out, BMA stamps were used as late as 1957 (Chang 2010), including revenue use until at least 1954 (Cockburn 2014).

References


previous section | next section | back to table of contents
Powered by SmugMug Log In