Spirit of Malaya - Lin Yangchen
©Lin Yangchen

previous section | next section | back to table of contents

Within a tiny space, a stamp must establish national identity, indicate its value, contain usefully suggestive symbolism and needs high visual impact…without compromising the dignity of the issuing authority.

—Stephen Bayley, British design critic

The coconut definitive is an enduring transcultural masterpiece of graphic design in which Malayan elements were built into its fundamental structure, rather than conveniently inserted as scenery framed by a generic decorative template as was done in many stamp designs. As Holley (2010a) put it, the coconut definitive was "not made to milk collectors or just adorn albums", compared with more recent times of "blatant exploitation".

Its woodcut quality exudes the old-world charm of traditional Malay woodcraft, and makes it look even more old-school than the 19th-century classics. It exploits the incisive detail and perceptual shade gradation of line art, yet retains the kampong simplicity and roughness—in fact, simpler than most of its highly embellished small-definitive contemporaries throughout the world. Gentleman (1972) thought letterpress was clumsy at such small scales, but I think it is a blessing in disguise. Indeed, it wouldn't have been out of place on the letters of rugged guerrillas prowling the jungles during the Malayan Emergency.

It unifies nature and architecture in the coconut tree, striking a mesmerizing balance between rustic tranquility and imperial grandeur. The abstinence from superfluous embellishment liberates the raw beauty and harmony of rectangular and elliptical geometric forms that remain recognisable from a distance. Moreover, it stands out among the world's classic imperial portrait-centric stamps in incorporating scenic elements without sacrificing its air of administrative authority.

The coconut design is so iconic that it has been reproduced and adapted several times, but never with the quality of the original. It has been reproduced on commemorative stamps with faster but inferior printing methods, adapted for invitation cards on which the handcut typefaces were substituted with computer fonts, and digitally redrawn with raster gradients and pictorial vignettes for a recent issue where the coconut trees were inexplicably reduced to spindly saplings that no longer provided structural support.

photograph by August E. Kaulfuss, pre-1914
printed in Germany

Times had changed by the twilight years of the coconut definitive. The 1960s saw a philatelic "industrial revolution" with the more pictorial photogravure technique, a fundamentally different kind of printing with multiple colours. Great stamps die hard (pun intended), however; the coconut definitives of Johore were still being printed as late as 1958, and a 1959 order was cancelled only because Sultan Ibrahim died (Stanway 2009). The last coconut definitives were finally invalidated on 1 November 1966 (Stanway 2009), nine years after independence and a year after Singapore separated from Malaysia, marking the end of a classic but remarkably future-proof design that had seen Malaya through some of the most tumultuous chapters in its history.

The diversity and longevity of the coconut definitive was choreographed by no mastermind. It was superb design and a little luck that gave it resilience and adaptability in the face of adversity and the tides of change.

The Monastery of St. Nuciferus in Bukit Timah, Singapore, consecrated by the author in 2018. Two splendid coconut palms, Cocos nucifera, adorn the stained-glass windows high above the ambulatory. ©Lin Yangchen


previous section | next section | back to table of contents
Powered by SmugMug Log In